
Short answer
Earnest money shows up twice in a 1031 exchange: the deposit your buyer puts down on the property you sell, and the deposit you put down on the replacement. On the sale side, the buyer's deposit should stay in escrow and go to your qualified intermediary at closing with the rest of the proceeds. If it is released to you early, that money is generally taxable. On the purchase side, you can pay the deposit from your own funds and let it count toward the price, or have the QI pay it from exchange funds once the contract is assigned. Having your own deposit refunded to you at closing from exchange money is cash out of the exchange.
| Deposit | Safe handling | What creates a problem |
|---|---|---|
| Buyer's deposit on your sale | Held by title or escrow, then sent to the QI at closing | Deposit paid straight to you, or released to you before closing |
| Your deposit on the replacement, before your sale closes | Pay it yourself; it counts toward the price at closing | Asking for it back in cash from exchange funds at closing |
| Your deposit on the replacement, after your sale closes | QI pays it from exchange funds after the contract is assigned | QI sends exchange money to you so you can pay it |
| Refund of a replacement deposit when a deal falls through | Refund goes back to the QI | Refund sent to you |
On this page
The rule behind it: don't touch exchange money
A deferred exchange works only if you never actually or constructively receive the sale money. Under Treas. Reg. §1.1031(k)-1(f) and (g), money you can receive, pledge or borrow against is treated as yours, and the exchange agreement must limit your rights to the funds. A deposit from your buyer is part of your sale proceeds, so it falls under the same rules. For other ways this can go wrong, see common constructive receipt scenarios.
Five situations and what to do
1. The buyer's deposit is held by title or escrow
This is the normal case and needs no special step. At closing the deposit is credited to the price and the full net proceeds, deposit included, are wired to the QI.
2. The buyer's deposit becomes non-refundable and is released early
Some contracts release the deposit, or extension payments, to the seller before closing. If that money goes to you, it is generally taxable as boot, even if the rest of the exchange works. If you sign the exchange agreement first, the release can usually be paid directly to the QI instead. Ask for that in the contract.
3. You sell without an agent and the buyer hands you a check
Don't deposit it. Have it made out to the title company or escrow agent, or to your QI once the exchange agreement is signed.
4. You need to put down a deposit on the replacement
If your sale has already closed, the QI can pay the deposit from exchange funds after the purchase contract is assigned to it. If your sale hasn't closed yet, there is no exchange money, so you pay the deposit yourself. That deposit counts toward the purchase price at closing, which is fine: you added cash to the replacement. Getting that deposit refunded to you from exchange funds at closing is generally treated as taking cash out, so leave it in the deal. See how added cash works.
5. The replacement deal falls through
If the QI paid the deposit and the contract is cancelled, the refund must go back to the QI, not to you, so it stays available for another property. Make sure the escrow instructions say so. If a deposit is forfeited, that money is gone from the exchange; ask your CPA how to treat it.
Worked example
| Step | Deposit | Handling |
|---|---|---|
| Sale contract signed; buyer deposits with title | $25,000 | Held by title |
| Buyer extends closing; contract releases $10,000 of the deposit to the seller | $10,000 | Paid to the QI under the signed exchange agreement, not to the seller |
| Sale closes | Remaining $15,000 | Credited at closing; all net proceeds wired to the QI |
| Replacement contract signed on day 20; assigned to the QI | $50,000 | Paid by the QI from exchange funds |
| Replacement closes on day 75 | $50,000 | Credited toward the price; no cash to the investor |
Had the $10,000 extension release been paid to the seller, that $10,000 would have been taxable, while the rest of the exchange would still have worked.
Checklist for agents and escrow officers
- Sale contract: deposit held by a neutral escrow holder; any early release payable to the QI.
- Exchange agreement signed before any release date.
- Purchase contract: assignment to the QI; refunds of deposits paid by the QI go back to the QI.
- Settlement statements show where each deposit went. See how to review the settlement statement.
For the full list of documents, see key 1031 exchange documents. Real estate agents can also read our guide for agents. To open an exchange before a deposit is released, start your exchange.
Frequently asked questions
Can I use 1031 exchange funds for an earnest money deposit?
Yes, once your sale has closed and the purchase contract is assigned to the QI. The QI pays the deposit directly from exchange funds.
What happens to the buyer's earnest money on my sale?
It should be held by title or escrow and credited at closing. The full net proceeds, deposit included, go to your QI.
Is a released earnest money deposit taxable in a 1031 exchange?
If it is paid to you, it is generally treated as cash you received and taxed as boot. If it is paid to the QI under a signed exchange agreement, it stays in the exchange.
Can I be reimbursed for a deposit I paid on the replacement?
Getting it back in cash from exchange funds at closing is generally treated as taking cash out of the exchange. Leaving it in the purchase price avoids the issue.
What if my replacement purchase is cancelled after the QI paid a deposit?
The refund should go back to the QI so it can be used for another identified property.
Sources
- Treas. Reg. §1.1031(k)-1 (actual and constructive receipt, and limits on the exchanger's rights to funds, §1.1031(k)-1(f) and (g))
- 26 U.S.C. §1031 (the exchange statute)
This article is general information, not tax or legal advice. Talk to your CPA or tax attorney about your situation.














