
Short answer
A tenancy-in-common (TIC) interest is a fractional, undivided ownership share in a property, with your own deed. Because you own real estate directly instead of owning a share of a partnership, a TIC interest can be a 1031 replacement property, and you can later exchange out of it on your own. The catch is control: co-owners must agree on major decisions, which is why most sponsored fractional deals today use a DST instead. TICs still work well for small groups who know each other and for splitting up partnerships.
| Question | Answer |
|---|---|
| What you own | An undivided percentage of the property, recorded on the deed |
| Qualifies for 1031? | Yes, if it is real co-ownership and not a disguised partnership |
| IRS guidance | Rev. Proc. 2002-22 (conditions for a ruling, not a safe harbor) |
| Maximum co-owners | 35 under Rev. Proc. 2002-22 |
| Big decisions | Sale, leases, refinancing and hiring a manager need unanimous consent |
| Can you exit alone? | Yes, you can sell or exchange your share, subject to any right of first offer |
On this page
Why TIC interests qualify and partnership interests don't
Section 1031 excludes partnership interests. If you own 20% of an LLC that owns a building, you own an LLC interest, not real estate, and you can't exchange it. If you own a 20% tenancy-in-common share of the same building, you own real estate. The IRS question is whether the co-owners are really just co-owners, or whether they are running a business together, which would make them a partnership for tax purposes no matter what the deed says.
The Rev. Proc. 2002-22 conditions
Rev. Proc. 2002-22 lists the conditions the IRS considers before ruling that a co-ownership is not a partnership. It is not a safe harbor, but sponsors and lawyers use it as the checklist.
| Condition | In plain terms |
|---|---|
| Tenancy in common under state law | Each owner holds title directly |
| No more than 35 co-owners | A married couple counts as one |
| No entity behavior | No partnership tax return, no business under a common name |
| Unanimous approval | Required for sale, leases, refinancing and hiring a manager |
| Free to transfer | Each owner can sell or encumber their share, except for limited rights of first offer |
| Proportional sharing | Income, expenses and debt are shared by ownership percentage |
| Limited activities | Only customary activities for owning and renting the property |
| Short management contracts | Management agreements renewable no more than a year at a time |
| Market-rate deals | Leases and payments to a sponsor at fair value, not based on the property's income |
Pros and cons
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Direct deed to real estate, so it is valid 1031 replacement property | Unanimity can freeze the property if one owner refuses a sale or new lease |
| Each owner can exchange out on their own timeline | Financing is harder: lenders often require each owner to hold title in a separate single-member LLC |
| Lets several smaller exchanges combine into a larger property | Capped at 35 owners |
| Depreciation and income pass to you by your percentage | A partition lawsuit is the last resort when owners deadlock |
| Useful to split a partnership so each partner goes their own way | Sponsored TICs sold widely before 2008 struggled in the downturn, which is why DSTs took over |
TIC vs DST vs LLC
| TIC | DST | Multi-member LLC | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1031 replacement? | Yes | Yes (Rev. Rul. 2004-86) | No, it is a partnership interest |
| Number of investors | Up to 35 | Often hundreds | Any |
| Your vote | Yes, unanimity on big decisions | None; the trustee decides | Per the operating agreement |
| Signing the loan | Often each owner or their LLC | No, the trust borrows | The LLC |
| Exit | Sell or exchange your share | When the sponsor sells | Only the LLC can exchange |
| Best for | Small groups who trust each other | Passive investors who want no decisions | Operating together, not exchanging separately |
For the DST side, read what a DST property is and DST pros and cons.
Two common ways TICs are used today
Drop and swap out of a partnership
Three partners own a building in an LLC. One wants cash, two want to exchange. The LLC deeds the building to the partners as tenants in common before the sale, so each can do their own thing with their share. Timing matters: the IRS can argue the partners didn't hold the TIC interests long enough for investment. See what a drop and swap is and the audit risks.
Friends or family buying together
Two siblings each sell a rental and exchange into one larger building as 50/50 tenants in common. Each does a separate exchange with their own intermediary account. A written co-ownership agreement covering decisions, buy-outs and what happens at death is essential. More on structures in 1031 exchanges with multiple owners.
Frequently asked questions
What is TIC vs JTWROS?
In a tenancy in common, each owner's share passes to their heirs when they die. In a joint tenancy with right of survivorship, the surviving owner automatically gets the share. TIC is the usual form for 1031 co-ownership because each owner controls and can exchange their own interest.
Can I do a 1031 exchange into a TIC?
Yes. A properly structured TIC interest is real property, so it qualifies as replacement property. Identify the TIC interest within 45 days like any other property.
Can an LLC do a 1031 exchange into a TIC?
Yes, the LLC can be one of the co-owners. But members of a multi-member LLC cannot exchange their LLC interests; only the LLC itself can exchange.
Is a TIC or a DST better for a 1031 exchange?
A DST suits investors who want no management role and a simple closing. A TIC suits a small group that wants a say and the ability to exit separately, and can live with unanimous decisions.
Sources
- 26 U.S.C. §1031 (partnership interests excluded)
- Rev. Proc. 2002-22 (co-ownership conditions)
- Rev. Rul. 2004-86 (DST interests as real property)
This article is general information, not tax or legal advice. Talk to your CPA or tax attorney about your situation.














